Vendor Risk Management & Its role in Data Privacy & Protection

Third Party Vendor Risk Management (TPRM) & Its role in Data Privacy & Protection

The financial services, healthcare, and telecommunications sectors are heavily reliant upon by consumers and, like many industries, have embraced outsourcing. These sectors depend significantly on third-party vendors for various aspects of their value chain.

Vendor Risk Management (VRM) is crucial for enterprises responsible for safeguarding sensitive data and ensuring comprehensive data privacy protection. This is particularly critical in highly regulated industries such as financial services, healthcare, and telecommunications, where the stakes are high for enterprises, both from the perspective of end-customers and regulators.

The Growing Vendor Ecosystem and Its Privacy Implications

A third-party vendor ecosystem brings substantial value to enterprises. With a complex network of suppliers, vendors, and business partners powering operational aspects, it introduces specialised expertise to serve the ultimate objective. This expansive ecosystem offers significant benefits, including cost savings, specialised knowledge, and improved operational efficiencies.

However, it also presents a critical challenge: the vulnerability to potential data privacy breaches originating from these third parties. This is especially concerning in light of the upcoming Digital Personal Data Protection (DPDP) Act, where fiduciaries will be held ultimately responsible for breaches.

Let's examine how these industries utilise the third-party vendor ecosystem and understand the sensitive Personally Identifiable Information (PII) and Protected Health Information (PHI) they handle:

💡

Financial Services: Financial records, account details, and personal information

💡

Healthcare Organisations: Electronic health records, genetic information, and personal medical histories

💡

Telecommunication Services: Customer communication patterns, related insights, location data, and online activities

The information involved is extremely sensitive, and any breach can cause significant harm to the individual it belongs to. This is how identity theft occurs, and victims often only become aware when the damage is so severe that making rectifications is extremely challenging.

Given the numerous moving parts in providing services to customers in these sectors, third-party vendors must be trusted to complete the value chain. Entrusting this valuable and highly regulated data to external vendors creates significant vulnerability.

A single weak link in the vendor chain can lead to widespread chaos—data exposure, compliance failures, and irreparable reputation damage. The risk from an enterprise perspective has intensified due to the evolving landscape of data privacy regulations, including the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) in the EU, the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) in the US, the Personal Data Protection Act (PDPA) in Singapore, the Telecommunications and Telemedia Data Protection Act (TTDSG) in Germany, and the recent Digital Personal Data Protection (DPDP) Act in India.

The Criticality of Vendor Risk Management for Data Privacy

A robust vendor risk management practice has become essential for organisations in these data-sensitive industries. By taking a proactive approach to identify, assess, and mitigate risks posed by third-party vendors, enterprises can safeguard their customers' privacy and ensure compliance with increasingly stringent regulatory requirements.

Let's explore the challenges third parties can expose enterprises to:

Third-Party Data Breaches and Compromises

The most significant risks associated with vendors are data breaches and cyber attacks originating from third-party vendors. Threat actors may target vendors with weaker security controls as a quick gateway to accessing data and systems of larger enterprises who are their clients.

Notable examples of security breaches include:

• The 2013 Target data breach, facilitated through a compromise of one of the retailer's HVAC vendors.

• The 2017 Equifax breach, linked to a vulnerability in a third-party web application framework.

Regulatory Compliance ChallengesI

n the evolving landscape of data privacy regulations, enterprises are now held accountable for the data privacy and security practices of their vendors, even if the actual breach occurs on the vendor's side. For instance, under the DPDP Act in India, a security lapse or data breach at a third-party vendor will be attributed to the enterprise's lack of compliance, potentially resulting in disciplinary action and penalties.Under the GDPR, organizations can be fined up to 4% of their global annual revenue for violations, including those involving the mishandling of personal data by a vendor. With the DPDP Act in India, this amount can reach up to USD 30 million.

‍Vendor Governance and Oversight Gaps

‍To effectively manage third-party vendors, enterprises must have comprehensive visibility and control over their expanding vendor ecosystem. This becomes especially critical when vendors employ their own sub-vendors in the lifecycle of their responsibilities.Manual onboarding processes often lead to inadequate monitoring of third-party activities, while reactive communication channels like email result in ineffective vendor communication. These factors create significant blind spots that threat actors can exploit to gain unauthorized access to sensitive data.

‍Supply Chain Vulnerabilities

‍Modern business operations require expertise at a granular level to make products or services accessible to a target audience, resulting in a complex value chain.The interconnectedness of third-party vendors means that a risk posed by a single vendor can quickly cascade through the entire value chain. A single compromise could potentially expose the data of numerous downstream customers, amplifying the privacy and reputational impact for an enterprise.

‍Vendor Mergers, Acquisitions, and Divestitures

‍One of the biggest challenges for growing enterprises is integrating new entities, both in terms of effort and potential risks. This challenge applies equally to organisational changes within the vendors as well.Mergers, acquisitions, and divestitures can introduce significant data privacy risks if not methodically managed. Merging datasets, integrating systems, and divesting business units all require careful planning and execution to ensure the continued protection of sensitive information.

‍Establishing a Comprehensive Vendor Risk Management Program

‍Let's examine what a comprehensive vendor risk management program should entail, considering the risks associated with financial services, healthcare, and telecommunications sectors.An effective vendor risk management program for these sectors should encompass the following key elements:

‍Vendor Onboarding and Due Diligence

‍Thoroughly vet prospective vendors during the onboarding process, evaluating their data privacy and security controls, compliance history, and overall risk profile. Establish clear contractual agreements that outline data privacy and security responsibilities.

‍Continuous Vendor Monitoring

‍Continuously monitor the performance, security posture, and compliance status of active vendors. Leverage automated tools and dashboards to maintain real-time visibility into vendor activities and quickly identify potential privacy-related issues.

‍Vendor Risk Assessments

‍Conduct regular, in-depth risk assessments to identify vulnerabilities, threats, and potential privacy impacts associated with each vendor. Use the insights gained to prioritise mitigation efforts and take informed ongoing vendor risk management decisions.

‍Incident Response and Business Continuity Planning

‍Develop robust incident response and business continuity plans that address vendor-related data privacy breaches and disruptions. Ensure clear communication protocols, escalation procedures, and recovery strategies are in place.

‍Vendor Governance and Oversight

‍Establish a centralised vendor governance framework to ensure consistent policy enforcement, risk management, and performance oversight across the entire vendor ecosystem. Designate clear roles, responsibilities, and escalation matrices for accountability.

‍Vendor Optimisation and Consolidation

‍Regularly review the vendor portfolio to identify opportunities for optimisation, consolidation, and strategic partnerships. Streamlining the vendor ecosystem can enhance visibility, improve risk management, and strengthen data privacy protection.Educate and train employees on the importance of vendor risk management and its role in safeguarding data privacy. Empower staff to identify and report potential vendor-related privacy issues.

‍Current State of Vendor Risk Management and Opportunities for Improvement

‍So where are we in our Vendor Risk Management practices, and what are some of our areas of improvement so we can mitigate these risks and have a very robust, reliable and effective vendor chain to fulfil the business needs?To understand this let us take a look at what is the current state of Vendor Risk ManagementCurrently & historically, vendor risk management has been a largely manual and reactive process for many enterprises.Organisations have and are still relying on labour-intensive methods, such as spreadsheet-based questionnaires, on-site audits, and periodic reviews, to assess and monitor third-party risks.This approach has proven to be time-consuming, prone to human error, and often unable to keep pace with the rapid changes in the vendor ecosystem.With the ever-evolving regulatory landscape, there are certain aspects that enterprises can take into account when designing and implementing their vendor risk management practices, and be not just automated and precise but also be adept at handling scale of vendor relationships while being in a proactive stance rather than a reactive one. And this is what we feel will be  a shot in the arm for managing third-party risks:

‍Automated Vendor Onboarding and Assessments:

‍Automation with the help of AI-powered solutions will not only streamline but also collect increasingly relevant data and with the correct analysis it can generate a comprehensive risk profile for the vendor. This will actually provide an enterprise with deeper insights to make more informed decisions with factual evidences about new and existing vendor vulnerabilities and highlight any potential privacy concerns early on in the relationship.

‍Continuous Vendor Monitoring:

‍Once a proper due diligence is done to setup a vendor, it becomes of critical importance to ensure  a continual monitoring of the vendor activities, adherence to security posture and compliance guidelines. By merging various data sources, such solutions can provide any enterprise with timely warnings about any emerging risks before they become a threat and thereby facilitating swift mitigation actions.

‍Predictive Analytics and Risk Modelling:

‍AI & Machine learning technologies and techniques can help organisations to preempt and quantify the potential impact of vendor-related data privacy breaches. This allows for the right mitigation efforts to be undertaken at the right priorities, and allows for optimal resource allocation, creating a data driven decision with a perfect audit trail for any inspections and audits by the regulatory authorities.

‍Integrated Risk Management:

‍As an enterprise, the Business Continuity is a really big ask and to form the right policy and practices to ensure this continuity, it is best advised to take a more holistic approach to risk management and integrate vendor risks with the risks from other domains such as cybersecurity and compliance. This allows a CISO or a CIO and eventually the business to develop an enterprise-wide understanding of risks and facilitates a coordinated response to vendor related privacy incidents, while managing the other touch points of impact in tandem.

‍Collaborative Vendor Engagement:

‍Since there are co-dependencies between multiple vendors to fulfil a value chain, it is best to configure the vendor risk management program for joint risk assessments, information sharing and develop mutually beneficial data privacy & protection strategies.This collaborative approach will help to build trust, improve transparency, and enhance the overall resilience of the vendor ecosystem.

‍Regulatory Alignment and Compliance Automation:

‍Data privacy regulations are evolving globally, with 71% of countries now having legislation-led data privacy regulations. Conducting business internationally will increasingly create complications, calling for automation in enterprises. These automations must include policy definition, enforcement, regulatory change management, and the creation of audit trails and comprehensive compliance reports.

‍Call to action: Embed privacy protections into all your vendor relationships

‍We have now realised that the supply chain for any business will be most optimal and fulfilling when it is modularised for speciality. This will cause the reliance on third-party vendors to grow, and grow rapidly for any enterprise. And it becomes even more critical for enterprises in the financial services, healthcare, and telecommunications sectors.So enterprises in these sectors must elevate their vendor risk management to a strategic priority and by proactively addressing the data privacy risks inherent in these complex vendor ecosystems, enterprises can protect their customers' sensitive information, ensure regulatory compliance, and maintain public trust - all while unlocking the benefits of a more efficient and agile business model.The journey towards robust vendor risk management for data privacy protection is going to be an ongoing one, requiring a combination of technology, processes, and cultural change. But for those enterprises that embrace this challenge, the rewards in terms of enhanced resilience, competitive advantage, and future-proofing are undeniable.